Car Accident Attorney Costs in Florida: What You'll Actually Pay
If you've been injured in a car accident, one of your first concerns is likely: âHow much will hiring an attorney cost me?â It's a valid question, especially when you're already facing medical bills, lost wages, and vehicle repair costs.
The good news: Most car accident victims pay nothing out of pocket to hire an experienced personal injury attorneyâand you only pay if your attorney wins your case.
Contingency Fee: The Foundation of Car Accident Cases
What Contingency Fee Means
No upfront payment required
You don't pay anything to hire the attorney
No hourly billing
The attorney doesn't charge by the hour for their time
Payment only if you win
The attorney only gets paid if they recover compensation
Fee comes from settlement
Payment as a percentage of your settlement or court award
Why Attorneys Use Contingency Fees
Access to Justice
Most accident victims cannot afford to pay $300-$500 per hour for legal representation. Contingency fees make experienced attorneys accessible to everyone.
Risk Sharing
The attorney assumes the financial risk of pursuing your case. If they lose, they've invested hundreds of hours with no compensation.
Motivation Alignment
When the attorney's payment depends on winning your case and maximizing your recovery, their incentives align perfectly with yours.
Typical Contingency Fee Percentages in Florida
Before Lawsuit
Standard rate if the case settles before filing a lawsuit
After Lawsuit Filed
Reflects additional work, risk, and time required for litigation
If Case Goes to Trial
Some attorneys increase fee through trial, others maintain 40%
Example: How Contingency Fees Work
Pre-Lawsuit Settlement ($100,000)
Trial Verdict ($150,000)
What âFree Consultationâ Really Means
What the Consultation Includes
- â30-60 minute meeting to discuss your accident and injuries
- âReview of accident details, police reports, and available evidence
- âPreliminary evaluation of whether you have a viable case
- âExplanation of the legal process and what to expect
- âDiscussion of potential compensation you might recover
- âNo obligation to hire the attorneyâyou can walk away with no cost
What the Consultation Doesn't Include
- âA commitment to take your case (the attorney evaluates merit first)
- âDetailed legal research into complex liability questions
- âNegotiation with insurance companies on your behalf
- âPreparation of legal documents or court filings
Once you formally hire the attorney, the contingency fee arrangement begins, but you still don't pay anything upfront.
Additional Costs and Expenses
Common Case Costs
Court Filing Fees
$400-$500 in Florida
Medical Records
$50-$200 per provider
Expert Witness Fees
$2,000-$10,000+ depending on case
Deposition Costs
$500-$1,500 per deposition
Investigation Costs
$500-$3,000
Police Reports
$10-$50
Simple Pre-Lawsuit Settlement
Lawsuit Filed, Settled Before Trial
Case Goes to Trial
Most personal injury firms advance all case costsâmeaning they pay these expenses as they arise. You pay nothing out of pocket. When the case settles, these costs are deducted from your recovery.
Does Hiring an Attorney Result in More Money?
The Research Says Yes
More compensation recovered by claimants with attorneys vs. unrepresented (Insurance Research Council)
Average settlement increase with attorney representation
Net recovery even after paying attorney fees
Real Example: Attorney vs. No Attorney
Without Attorney
With Attorney (33.33% fee)
That's $26,555 more in your pocketânearly triple what you would have received alone.
Why Attorneys Achieve Better Results
Knowledge of True Case Value
Experienced attorneys understand what cases are actually worth based on injury severity, medical costs, wage loss, and pain and suffering. Insurance companies count on unrepresented claimants accepting lowball offers.
Negotiation Skills and Leverage
Personal injury attorneys are skilled negotiators who understand insurance company tactics. They also have the credibility and resources to file a lawsuit if necessary, which provides leverage.
Medical Evidence Development
Attorneys know how to work with doctors to document injuries properly, obtain the right diagnostic tests, and secure compelling medical opinions that support higher settlements.
Avoiding Common Mistakes
Unrepresented claimants frequently make costly mistakes: giving harmful recorded statements, accepting quick settlements before understanding injury extent, or missing critical deadlines.
Questions to Ask About Attorney Fees
- 1
âWhat is your contingency fee percentage?â
Confirm the exact percentage for pre-lawsuit settlement, after lawsuit filed, and at trial
- 2
âHow do you handle case costs?â
Do they advance costs, or are you responsible?
- 3
âWhat happens to costs if we lose?â
Are you required to reimburse costs, or does the firm absorb them?
- 4
âIs the fee calculated before or after costs are deducted?â
Some firms calculate fees on gross recovery, others on net after costs
- 5
âAre there any other fees or charges?â
Some firms charge administrative fees, though this is uncommon
- 6
âWill you put the fee agreement in writing?â
Florida requires written fee agreements, so this should always be yes
Red Flags: When to Avoid an Attorney
When Should You Hire an Attorney?
Consider hiring a car accident attorney if:
You suffered any injury beyond truly minor cuts or bruises
Your medical bills exceed $5,000
You missed work due to accident injuries
Fault is disputed or unclear
Multiple vehicles were involved
The insurance company denied your claim or offered unreasonably low settlement
You were hit by a commercial or government vehicle
Your injuries may be permanent or require ongoing treatment
Note: You typically don't need an attorney for minor property damage with no injuries where liability is clear and the insurance company makes a fair offer.
The Bottom Line on Car Accident Attorney Costs
Most work on contingency: You pay nothing upfront and nothing unless you win
Standard fees are 33.33%-40%: One-third before lawsuit, 40% after lawsuit filed
Free consultations are truly free: No obligation and no cost to meet with an attorney
Costs are separate from fees: Case expenses are additional but usually advanced by the firm
You'll likely get more money with an attorney: Even after paying fees, represented claimants net significantly more
Get everything in writing: Florida requires written fee agreements explaining all costs
Get Expert Representation Without Upfront Costs
At Cardinal Law, we handle all car accident cases on a contingency fee basis. You pay nothing unless we recover compensation for you. Our experienced personal injury attorneys have helped thousands of Florida accident victims maximize their recoveriesâoften achieving settlements 3-5 times higher than insurance company initial offers.
We advance all case costs, provide free consultations, and work aggressively to ensure you receive every dollar you deserve.
Call 239-610-0845or call 844-874-PAIN for a free consultation
Don't let concerns about attorney costs prevent you from getting the legal help you need. With contingency fees, there's no financial risk to hiring experienced representationâonly the potential for significantly greater compensation.
Wondering What Your Case May Be Worth?
Let's work on your case together
Through 13 years of experience and multi-millions recovered for our clients we offer the most premium legal services.
Visit Our Florida Offices
Cardinal Law has offices throughout Florida to serve you better. Our main office is in Naples, with additional locations by appointment.
Naples Office
Main Office9045 Strada Stell Court
Suite 305
Naples, FL 34109
Orlando Office
200 E Robinson Street
Suite 1120
Orlando, FL 32801
Tampa Office
401 East Jackson Street
Suite 2340
Tampa, FL 33602
Miami Office
848 Brickell Avenue
Suite PH5
Miami, FL 33131
Fort Myers Office
5237 Summerlin Commons Blvd
Suite 511
Fort Myers, FL 33907
Š 2026 Cardinal Law, P.A. All rights reserved.