Piercing the Corporate Veil in Florida: When You Can Reach an LLC's Owners
LLCs and corporations usually protect their owners from business debts. Florida courts will look past that protection only in narrow situations. Here is what it takes.
One of the main reasons people form an LLC or corporation is to keep business debts separate from their personal assets. If the business cannot pay, creditors are generally limited to what the business owns. That protection is real, and Florida courts take it seriously.
But it is not absolute. In limited circumstances, a court can disregard the company and hold the people behind it personally responsible. That is called piercing the corporate veil.
Can you sue an LLC?
Yes. An LLC or corporation can be sued in its own name, just like a person. If you have a contract with a company, the company is usually the right defendant. The harder question is whether you can also reach the owners when the company has no money left.
What Florida courts require to pierce the veil
Florida sets a high bar. Under the Florida Supreme Court's long-standing test, a party generally must show:
- The owner dominated and controlled the company to the point that it had no real independent existence and was a mere instrumentality or "alter ego" of the owner.
- The owner used the company form fraudulently or for an improper purpose.
- That improper use caused the plaintiff's loss.
The second element is where many claims fall short. It is not enough that a company is owned by one person, that it is undercapitalized, or that it simply failed to pay a debt. Courts generally want to see something like using the company to hide assets, mislead creditors, or dodge an obligation the owner knew about.
Facts that tend to matter
- Mixing personal and business money, such as paying personal bills from the company account.
- Moving company assets to the owner or a related company right before or after a debt came due.
- Ignoring basic formalities so the company is a shell in name only.
- Creating a new company to continue the same business and leave the old debts behind.
- Misrepresenting who you were dealing with or what assets the company had.
No single factor decides the case. Courts look at the whole picture.
Other ways to reach the people behind a company
Veil piercing is often a last resort. In practice, there are frequently easier paths to the people involved:
- Personal guarantees. If an owner signed a guaranty, they can be sued directly on it.
- Personal wrongdoing. Owners and officers can be personally liable for their own torts, such as fraud or fraudulent inducement, even when acting for the company.
- Fraudulent transfers. Florida's Uniform Fraudulent Transfer Act can let a creditor undo transfers made to avoid paying a debt.
- Statutory liability. Certain statutes impose personal liability in specific situations.
Practical tips for businesses extending credit
The best protection is upfront. When you extend credit or sign a significant contract with a closely held company, consider asking for a personal guaranty, a deposit, or security. Check the company's status on Florida's Sunbiz database before you sign. And document who you are dealing with in your contract.
If a company owes you money and you suspect its owners moved assets out of reach, our business litigation attorneys can evaluate whether veil piercing, a fraudulent transfer claim, or another remedy fits. Contact us to schedule a consultation.
Sources
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I sue the owner of an LLC personally in Florida?
Generally not just for the company's debts. You may be able to reach an owner who signed a personal guaranty, who personally committed fraud or another tort, or, in narrow cases, by piercing the corporate veil.
Is a single-member LLC easier to pierce?
Single ownership by itself is not enough. Florida courts still require domination of the company plus improper or fraudulent use of the company form that caused the loss.
What is a fraudulent transfer?
A transfer of assets made to hinder, delay, or defraud creditors, or made for less than reasonable value while the debtor was insolvent. Florida law allows creditors to challenge these transfers.