Cardinal Law represents businesses and business owners in commercial disputes in Naples, Collier County, Lee County and across Southwest Florida. We also work with clients elsewhere in Florida. Our goal is to understand what the dispute is really costing you, what you want the business to look like when it is over, and which path gets you there with the least damage.
Sometimes that means a firm letter and a negotiated fix. Sometimes it means filing suit. We will tell you plainly what we see in your documents and what the realistic options are.
Matters we handle
Contract Disputes
When a customer will not pay, a supplier stops performing or a deal falls apart, we help you understand your contract rights and enforce or defend them.
Read more →Partnership & Shareholder Disputes
Disputes between partners, LLC members and shareholders of closely held companies, including deadlock, owners being shut out, misuse of company funds, buyouts and dissolution.
Read more →What business litigation covers
Business litigation is a broad term for lawsuits and arbitrations between companies, between owners of the same company, or between a business and the people it deals with. Our practice focuses on two main areas, each with its own page:
- Contract disputes: unpaid invoices, missed deliveries, defective work, broken purchase agreements, leases, service agreements and vendor contracts.
- Partnership, shareholder and LLC member disputes: deadlock, owners being shut out of the business, misuse of company money, buyouts and breakups.
Other commercial matters
Business disputes do not always fit neatly into one category. We also handle related claims that often show up alongside a contract or ownership fight, such as:
- Breach of fiduciary duty by officers, directors, managers or partners.
- Fraud and misrepresentation in the sale of a business or in a commercial deal.
- Tortious interference, for example when a competitor or former partner works to break up your contracts or customer relationships.
How a business dispute usually moves
Every case is different, but most follow a similar path. Knowing the steps ahead of time helps you plan for cost, time and disruption to the business.
- Review and demand. We read the contract and the paper trail, then usually send a written demand that lays out the problem and what you want done about it.
- Pre-suit negotiation. Many disputes settle here, especially when both sides still want to do business together or when the facts are clear.
- Filing suit. If the matter does not resolve, most local cases are filed in the circuit court for Collier County or Lee County. Some cases belong in federal court, for example when the parties are from different states and the amount in dispute is large enough.
- Arbitration. If your contract has an arbitration clause, the dispute may have to be decided by an arbitrator instead of a judge or jury. These clauses are common in commercial agreements and can change timing, cost and appeal rights.
- Mediation. Florida courts regularly send civil cases to mediation, where a neutral mediator helps the parties try to reach a settlement before trial.
- Trial or final hearing. Cases that do not settle are decided by a judge, a jury or an arbitrator.
What to gather before you meet with a lawyer
You do not need to have everything organized. But the more of the following you can bring, the more useful the first meeting will be:
- The contract, operating agreement, shareholder agreement or partnership agreement, including all amendments.
- Emails, texts and letters with the other side, especially anything about the problem.
- Invoices, payment records, bank statements and other financial records that show what was paid, what was owed and when.
- A short timeline in your own words of what happened and when.
- Any demand letters, notices of default or court papers you have received.
- A list of the people involved and their roles.
Acting early matters
Business disputes get harder to fix with time. Records get lost, money moves and positions harden. Some contracts also require written notice of a problem, and the law limits how long you have to file suit.
If you are not sure whether you have a claim or how much time you have, it is worth finding out sooner rather than later. Contact us to schedule a consultation.
Frequently asked questions
Do you represent businesses or individual owners?
Both. We represent companies of different sizes as well as individual owners, partners, members and shareholders. In an ownership dispute, we represent one side, not the company and an owner at the same time if their interests conflict.
Will my business dispute end up in court?
Not necessarily. Many disputes resolve through a demand letter, negotiation or mediation. If the other side will not deal reasonably, or a deadline is approaching, filing suit or starting arbitration may be the right move. We will discuss the tradeoffs with you before deciding.
Can I get my attorney fees back if I win?
In Florida, each side usually pays its own attorney fees unless a contract or statute says otherwise. Many commercial contracts include a clause that awards fees to the prevailing party, so it is worth checking your agreement early.
What if my contract requires arbitration?
Courts generally enforce arbitration clauses in commercial contracts. That means your dispute may be heard by an arbitrator rather than a judge. Arbitration can be private and sometimes faster, but it has its own costs and limited appeal rights. We can review the clause and explain how it affects your case.
How long does a business lawsuit take?
It depends on the complexity of the dispute, how much information has to be exchanged, the court's schedule and whether the parties are willing to settle. Some matters resolve in weeks. Others take a year or more. We will give you a realistic sense of timing once we understand the facts.
Do you handle cases outside Collier and Lee County?
Our work is centered in Naples and Southwest Florida, and we also represent clients in other parts of Florida. Contact us to schedule a consultation and we can talk about where your case would be heard.
This page is general information, not legal advice. Reading it or contacting us does not create an attorney-client relationship. Deadlines and outcomes depend on the facts of each matter and the terms of any contract involved.