A common example: two people each own half of an LLC. After a falling out, one changes the passwords, removes the other from the bank account and stops sharing financial reports. The locked-out owner still has personal guaranties on the company's loans but no say in how it is run.
Cardinal Law represents partners, LLC members and shareholders of closely held corporations in Naples and Southwest Florida in these disputes. We help owners protect their stake, get information they are entitled to, and work toward a resolution, whether that is a new arrangement, a buyout or a breakup.
Who we represent
The rules that apply depend on what kind of entity you own and what your governing documents say. We work with:
- Members and managers of limited liability companies, which are governed in Florida by the Florida Revised Limited Liability Company Act, chapter 605, Florida Statutes, along with the company's operating agreement.
- Shareholders, directors and officers of closely held corporations, governed by the Florida Business Corporation Act, chapter 607, Florida Statutes, the bylaws and any shareholder agreement.
- General and limited partners in partnerships and joint ventures.
Common ownership disputes
Some of the situations we see most often include:
- Deadlock, where owners with equal votes cannot agree on major decisions and the business stalls.
- Minority owners being shut out: removed from management, cut off from distributions or denied information while the majority keeps running the company.
- An owner using company money for personal expenses or paying themselves outside what was agreed.
- An owner diverting customers, contracts or opportunities to a separate business.
- Disagreements over capital calls, dilution or the value of an owner's interest.
- Disputes when an owner wants to leave, retires, becomes disabled or passes away.
Fiduciary duties between owners and managers
People who manage a business owe duties to the company and, in some cases, to the other owners. These generally include a duty of loyalty, which means not putting personal interests ahead of the company, and a duty of care in how the business is run.
What those duties look like in practice depends on the type of entity, who is managing it and what the governing documents say. Operating agreements in particular can change some default rules. A breach of fiduciary duty claim may be brought on behalf of the company in some cases, and directly by an owner in others. Sorting out which applies is an early and important step.
Books and records demands
Owners who are on the outside often do not know the full picture. Florida law gives LLC members, shareholders and partners rights to inspect certain company records, subject to conditions and limits set by statute and the governing documents.
A properly written records demand is often the first formal step in an ownership dispute. It can reveal whether money is missing, show how the business is really doing and help value your interest. If the company refuses a proper demand, a court can be asked to order access.
Paths to resolution
Not every ownership dispute ends in a lawsuit. Depending on the facts and your goals, the options can include:
- Negotiating new terms for how the business is run.
- A buyout of one owner by the others or by the company, using any buy-sell provision in the governing documents or a negotiated price.
- Mediation with a neutral mediator.
- Claims for damages, an accounting or other relief from a court or arbitrator.
- Judicial dissolution, where a court can order a company wound up in certain situations, such as deadlock or misconduct by those in control.
Protect yourself while the dispute plays out
Keep copies of documents you are entitled to have. Do not take company property or delete records. Be careful about what you put in writing to your co-owner. And review any personal guaranties you have signed, because your exposure may not end just because you are out of management. Contact us to schedule a consultation to talk through your situation.
Frequently asked questions
My co-owner locked me out of the business. What can I do?
Start by gathering what you have: the operating agreement or shareholder agreement, any financial records and communications. A written records demand and a letter laying out your rights are common first steps. If the conduct is serious, a court may be asked for faster relief.
We have no operating agreement. What rules apply?
If an LLC has no operating agreement, or the agreement does not address an issue, Florida's Revised LLC Act fills in default rules. Those defaults may not match what the owners expected, so it is important to review them early.
Can I force my partner to buy me out?
Not automatically. A buyout right usually comes from the governing documents or from a negotiated agreement. In some court cases involving dissolution, a buyout can become part of the resolution. We can review your documents and explain what leverage you have.
How is my ownership interest valued?
It depends on the governing documents and the circumstances. Some agreements set a formula or appraisal process. Otherwise, value is often disputed and may require review by a business valuation professional. Questions such as whether discounts apply for a minority stake can make a large difference.
Can a court dissolve our company?
Yes, in certain circumstances. Florida law allows owners to ask a court to dissolve an LLC or corporation on specific grounds, such as deadlock that harms the business or illegal, oppressive or fraudulent conduct by those in control. Dissolution is a serious step, and courts consider whether other remedies are available.
Should I keep working in the business while this is going on?
Often yes, if you can do so safely, since walking away can affect your rights and your leverage. But every situation is different. Talk with a lawyer before you resign, stop working or take any company property.
This page is general information, not legal advice. Reading it or contacting us does not create an attorney-client relationship. Deadlines and outcomes depend on the facts of each matter and the terms of any contract involved.