Cardinal Law helps people on different sides of these disputes: property owners, general contractors, subcontractors and material suppliers in Naples, Collier County, Lee County and the rest of Southwest Florida. We review contracts, explain rights and deadlines, try to resolve disputes before they become lawsuits, and litigate when a case can't be settled.
Construction disputes move on short timelines. Lien deadlines, notice requirements and contract claim procedures can cut off rights that would otherwise be strong. If something on your project has started to go wrong, the earlier you get advice, the more options you are likely to have.
Matters we handle
Construction Defects
Claims and defense involving defective construction, including Florida's chapter 558 pre-suit notice process, hidden defects and repair disputes.
Read more →Construction Liens
Recording, enforcing and defending against construction liens under Florida's Construction Lien Law, for contractors, subs, suppliers and property owners.
Read more →Payment & Contract Disputes
Nonpayment, retainage, change orders, backcharges, termination and payment bond claims for owners, contractors, subcontractors and suppliers.
Read more →Construction work in Southwest Florida
Building in this part of the state has its own pressures. After a hurricane, owners need repairs fast and contractors are stretched across many jobs at once. That combination can lead to rushed scopes of work, loose change orders and disagreements about what was promised and what it should cost.
Condominium and HOA projects raise their own questions, from who has authority to sign a contract to how repair costs get allocated. Custom homes involve long build schedules, many trades and a lot of money moving through draws. Commercial build-outs depend on tight timelines tied to lease dates. In each setting, small paperwork gaps early in the job can turn into large disputes at the end.
Who we work with
Construction disputes look different depending on where you sit in the chain. We work with:
- Property owners, including homeowners, condominium and homeowners associations, and commercial owners dealing with defective work, delays, or liens on their property
- General contractors facing nonpayment, owner claims of defective work, or disputes with subcontractors
- Subcontractors and specialty trades trying to collect for work performed, retainage, or extra work
- Material suppliers who delivered materials to a job and have not been paid
Common construction disputes we handle
Most of the matters we see fall into a few categories, and many cases involve more than one:
- Construction defects, such as water intrusion, roofing and stucco failures, structural issues, and work that does not meet the plans, the contract or the building code
- Construction liens under Florida's Construction Lien Law, whether you need to record a lien to get paid or need to remove one from your property
- Payment disputes, including unpaid invoices, withheld retainage, backcharges and slow payment up and down the chain
- Delay and change-order disputes, including who pays for extra work, schedule overruns and claims for added costs
- Termination disputes, when an owner or contractor ends the contract and the other side says it was wrongful
- Claims involving contractor licensing or bonds, where a licensing complaint or a claim against a bond may be one of the available paths
Contract review and advice before a dispute starts
The cheapest construction dispute is the one that never happens. Before you sign, it helps to understand how the contract handles payment timing, change orders, delays, warranties, termination, and how disputes get resolved. Some contracts require arbitration or mediation. Some shift risk heavily to one side. Some say little about what happens if the job runs long.
We review and help draft construction contracts and subcontracts, and we advise clients in the middle of a project when something starts to slip. A short call while a problem is still small, such as how to document a change order or respond to a notice of default, can save a great deal of time and money later.
How a construction case usually unfolds
Every matter is different, but most follow a similar path. We start by reviewing the contract, the payment history, change orders, correspondence, photos and any notices that have gone out. Then we look at deadlines, because in construction cases a missed deadline can matter more than the strength of the underlying claim.
From there, many disputes are resolved through negotiation, a demand letter, or mediation. Defect claims often need an expert witness, such as an engineer or building consultant, to explain what went wrong and what a proper repair would cost. If the contract calls for arbitration, the case goes there. If not, and the dispute cannot be settled, we file suit or defend the suit filed against you in the appropriate Florida court.
What to do if a problem is developing on your project
A few practical steps help in almost every construction dispute:
- Keep everything in writing, including change requests, approvals and complaints about the work
- Save contracts, invoices, pay applications, lien waivers, notices and photos in one place
- Note key dates, especially the date work started and the last date you furnished labor or materials
- Read the notice and dispute sections of your contract before sending or answering a formal notice
- Get advice before you stop work, withhold payment, or terminate a contract, since each of those steps can change your position
Frequently asked questions
Do you represent owners or contractors?
We work with property owners, general contractors, subcontractors and suppliers. Before taking on any matter we check for conflicts, so we can't represent you if we already represent someone on the other side of your project.
Is this the same as a construction accident case?
No. This practice area covers disputes about construction contracts, payment, liens and the quality of the work. If someone was hurt on a job site, that is a personal injury matter, which our firm handles separately through its construction injuries practice.
How quickly should I contact a lawyer about a construction dispute?
As soon as you sense a real problem. Florida's lien and notice deadlines are short and strictly applied, and many contracts have their own notice requirements. Waiting until the project is over can mean some options are already gone.
My contract has an arbitration clause. Can you still help?
Yes. Many construction contracts require arbitration or mediation instead of a court case. We handle disputes in arbitration and mediation as well as in court, and we can tell you whether the clause applies to your situation.
Do you help with projects outside Naples?
We work with clients throughout Southwest Florida, including Collier County and Lee County. Contact us to discuss where your project is located.
How do I get started?
Contact us to schedule a consultation. Bring your contract, invoices, photos and any notices you have sent or received, and we can talk through where things stand and what your options are.
This page is general information, not legal advice. Reading it or contacting us does not create an attorney-client relationship. Deadlines and outcomes depend on the facts of each matter and the terms of any contract involved.