Cardinal Law helps contractors, subcontractors, suppliers and owners in Naples and throughout Southwest Florida sort out payment and contract disputes. That includes unpaid invoices and retainage, fights over extra work, backcharges, terminations, and claims against payment bonds.
Nonpayment and slow payment
Slow payment is common in construction, and not every late check means a dispute. But when invoices sit for months, or a GC keeps saying the owner hasn't paid yet, it is time to look at the contract and your options.
Many subcontracts include pay-when-paid or pay-if-paid language. Those clauses can affect when payment is due and, in some cases, whether it is due at all if the owner never pays. Florida courts read these clauses closely, and the exact wording matters. Florida also has prompt payment rules for some private and public projects that set timeframes for payment and may allow interest on late payments. Whether they apply depends on the type of project and the contract.
Retainage
Retainage is the portion of each payment held back until the job is finished, meant to make sure the work gets completed and punch-list items get done. Disputes come up when the project is done but the retainage never arrives, or when it is withheld to cover alleged defects or delays.
The contract usually controls how much can be held and when it must be released. On some public projects, Florida law also places limits on retainage. If you are owed retainage, keep track of substantial and final completion dates and any requests you made for release.
Change orders and extra work
Many payment disputes start with work that was added in the field. The owner asks for something on site, the contractor does it, and nobody signs a change order. At the end of the job, the contractor bills for it and the owner says it was part of the original scope.
Whether extra work is payable depends on the contract's change order procedures, what was said and written at the time, and how the parties behaved during the job. Written approvals, even an email or a text, make a big difference.
- Get written direction before starting extra work whenever possible
- Follow the contract's notice requirements for changes, delays and claims
- Track extra labor, materials and time separately as the work happens
- Respond in writing when you disagree with a change or a backcharge
Backcharges and termination
A backcharge is a deduction from payment for costs the GC or owner claims the sub caused, such as cleanup, repairs or delay. Some backcharges are legitimate. Others are used to avoid paying a balance that is actually owed. The contract and the documentation usually decide which.
Termination disputes are often the most expensive. A contract may allow termination for default, if one side fails to perform after notice and a chance to cure, or termination for convenience, which allows ending the contract without fault but usually with payment for work performed. A termination that does not follow the contract's procedures can turn the terminating party into the one in breach. Get advice before sending, or answering, a notice of default.
Payment bond claims
On many public projects, liens against the property are not available. Instead, Florida law generally requires the prime contractor to provide a payment bond, under section 255.05, Florida Statutes, for many state and local government projects. Subcontractors and suppliers who are not paid can make a claim against that bond. Some private projects also have payment bonds.
Bond claims have their own notice requirements and deadlines, which differ from lien deadlines and depend on the project, the bond and your place in the chain. We help claimants identify the bond, serve the required notices, and pursue payment, and we help contractors and sureties respond to bond claims.
Frequently asked questions
My general contractor says it hasn't been paid by the owner. Do I have to wait?
It depends on your subcontract. Some pay-when-paid clauses only affect timing, while pay-if-paid language may shift the risk of owner nonpayment to you. Florida courts read these clauses closely. You may also have lien or bond rights that do not depend on what the GC says.
Can I stop work if I am not being paid?
Sometimes, but it is risky. Stopping work without a clear right under the contract can be treated as a breach. Check the contract and get advice before walking off a job.
Do I get paid for extra work if there was no signed change order?
Possibly. Even without a signed change order, you may be able to recover for extra work based on written direction, the parties' conduct, or other legal theories. The contract terms and your records will matter a great deal.
What is the difference between a lien claim and a bond claim?
A lien is a claim against the property itself. A payment bond claim is a claim against a bond posted by a surety to secure payment, and is common on public projects where liens generally are not available. Each has its own notice rules and deadlines.
Can I recover interest or attorney fees in a payment dispute?
Sometimes. The contract may provide for them, and some Florida statutes allow interest on late payments or fees to the prevailing party in certain cases. Whether they are available depends on the contract and the claims involved.
How do I get started?
Contact us to schedule a consultation. Bring your contract, invoices, photos and any notices you have sent or received, and we can talk through where things stand and what your options are.
This page is general information, not legal advice. Reading it or contacting us does not create an attorney-client relationship. Deadlines and outcomes depend on the facts of each matter and the terms of any contract involved.