Cardinal Law handles construction defect matters for owners, associations and contractors in Naples and across Southwest Florida. We look at what went wrong, who may be responsible, what Florida law requires before a lawsuit can be filed, and whether repair or money damages makes more sense.
Patent defects and latent defects
Florida law treats defects differently depending on whether they could have been found through a reasonable inspection. A patent defect is one you could see or should have noticed, such as missing trim or visibly uneven tile. A latent defect is hidden, such as improperly installed flashing behind the stucco or missing reinforcement inside a wall.
The difference matters because of timing. The law limits how long you have to bring a defect claim, and some limits can apply even when the problem was hidden. Those limits depend on the facts, so it is worth getting advice as soon as you suspect a defect rather than waiting to see whether it gets worse.
Florida's pre-suit notice process under chapter 558
Before filing most residential and commercial construction defect lawsuits, Florida law requires the owner or association to go through a pre-suit process under chapter 558, Florida Statutes. In general terms, it works like this:
The process can feel slow, but it often leads to repairs or a settlement without a lawsuit. It also creates a record. How the notice is written, and how the contractor responds, can affect the case later. Contractors who receive a 558 notice should take it seriously and respond within the required time, since ignoring it can create problems of its own.
- The claimant serves a written notice of claim describing the defects in reasonable detail, a set period before filing suit
- The contractor and others who receive the notice can inspect the property and may forward the notice to subcontractors, suppliers or design professionals involved in the work
- Each party responds in writing, and may offer to repair, offer to pay, dispute the claim, or some combination
- The claimant can accept or reject the offer, and if the dispute is not resolved, the claimant may then file suit
Who can be responsible for a construction defect
Defect cases often involve more than one party, and responsibility is not always where it first appears. Depending on the contracts and the facts, claims may involve:
Sorting out who did what usually requires an expert witness, often an engineer or building consultant, who can inspect the work, identify the cause, and explain it in plain terms to the other side, a mediator, or a judge.
- The general contractor, who is usually responsible for the overall work under the prime contract
- Subcontractors, such as roofers, framers, stucco and window installers, whose work may be the direct cause
- Design professionals, such as architects and engineers, if the problem traces to the plans or specifications
- Manufacturers and suppliers, if a product or material was defective
Documenting a defect
Good documentation makes a defect claim stronger and helps a contractor respond fairly. If you suspect a defect, start a simple file:
- Date-stamped photos and video of the problem, taken over time if it is getting worse
- The contract, plans, specifications, change orders and any warranty documents
- Emails and texts with the contractor about the problem and any repair attempts
- Inspection reports, permits and the certificate of occupancy or completion
- Receipts for emergency repairs or steps you took to prevent more damage
Repair or damages?
Many owners simply want the work fixed. Sometimes letting the original contractor make the repair is the fastest, most practical result. Other times trust has broken down, or the contractor lacks the ability to do it right, and the better path is to recover the cost of having someone else make the repair.
Damages in a defect case may include the reasonable cost of repair, related damage to other parts of the property, and in some cases other losses tied to the defect. What is recoverable depends on the contract, the type of claim and the facts. For contractors, the same questions apply in reverse: whether the claimed defect is real, whether it is your work or someone else's, and whether the proposed repair is reasonable.
Frequently asked questions
What is a chapter 558 notice?
It is a written notice of claim that Florida generally requires before a construction defect lawsuit can be filed. It gives the contractor and others involved a chance to inspect and to offer a repair or payment before litigation starts.
I received a 558 notice as a contractor. What should I do?
Read it carefully, note the response deadline, and notify your insurer and any subcontractors whose work is involved. Your written response matters, so get advice before you send it.
The defect showed up years after the work was done. Is it too late?
Not necessarily. Some time limits run from when a defect was discovered or should have been discovered. But Florida also has outside limits that can bar claims after a certain number of years, so you should get advice promptly.
Should I fix the problem myself before talking to a lawyer?
Take reasonable steps to prevent further damage, such as stopping an active leak, and document everything before and after. Avoid major permanent repairs until the defect has been documented and, where possible, inspected, since that evidence may be needed later.
Can a condo or HOA bring a construction defect claim?
Associations can bring defect claims in many situations, often involving common elements. These claims raise their own questions about authority and notice to members, and the 558 process can have different timing for associations.
How do I get started?
Contact us to schedule a consultation. Bring your contract, invoices, photos and any notices you have sent or received, and we can talk through where things stand and what your options are.
This page is general information, not legal advice. Reading it or contacting us does not create an attorney-client relationship. Deadlines and outcomes depend on the facts of each matter and the terms of any contract involved.