Demand Letters: What to Send Before You Sue a Florida Business
A well-written demand letter can get you paid without a lawsuit, and a poorly written one can hurt your case. Here is what a demand letter should include and when Florida law requires notice before suit.
Before most business lawsuits are filed, someone sends a demand letter. It is a formal written request, usually for payment, that tells the other side what you believe they owe, why, and what will happen if they do not pay.
A demand letter is not legally required in every case, but it is usually worth sending. Plenty of disputes end with a well-written letter. And when they do not, the letter becomes part of the record that shows you gave the other side a fair chance to resolve it.
What a good demand letter includes
- Who you are and the relationship between the parties.
- The agreement or obligation involved, such as a contract, invoice, purchase order, or promissory note.
- What went wrong, stated as facts with dates.
- The exact amount demanded and how you calculated it.
- A clear deadline to pay or respond.
- What you intend to do if the matter is not resolved.
Attach or reference the key documents. If the contract has an attorney's fee clause, an interest provision, or a dispute resolution clause, mention it. Those terms often move the other side more than anything else in the letter.
Mistakes that can hurt your case
- Exaggerating the amount owed. If the number is not supportable, it undercuts everything else.
- Threatening criminal charges to collect a civil debt. This can create legal exposure for the sender.
- Making admissions. Statements like "we know the job was late, but" can show up later as evidence.
- Setting deadlines you do not plan to enforce.
- Writing in anger. Assume a judge will read every word.
When Florida law requires notice before suit
Some claims require specific pre-suit notice by statute or by contract, and skipping that step can delay or derail the case. A few examples:
- Construction defect claims against contractors, subcontractors, suppliers, and design professionals generally require a written notice under Chapter 558 of the Florida Statutes before filing suit. We cover that process in our post on latent construction defects.
- Many commercial contracts require written notice of default and an opportunity to cure before the other side can be sued or the contract terminated.
- Contracts with mediation or arbitration clauses may require those steps before or instead of a lawsuit. See mediation vs. arbitration.
Read the contract before sending the letter. If it requires notice in a particular form, to a particular address, or with a particular cure period, follow it exactly.
Should a lawyer send it?
You can send your own demand letter, and for small amounts that is often reasonable. A letter on law firm letterhead tends to signal that you are prepared to follow through, and an attorney can make sure the letter satisfies any notice requirements, preserves your claims, and does not create problems for you later.
What happens after the deadline
If the deadline passes, you have a decision to make. Options include filing suit, demanding arbitration if the contract requires it, filing in small claims court for smaller amounts, or negotiating a payment plan. The best choice depends on the amount at stake, the strength of your documentation, whether the other side can pay a judgment, and whether you can recover attorney's fees.
If a business owes you money or has breached a contract, our business litigation attorneys can prepare a demand letter and advise you on next steps. Contact us to schedule a consultation.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a demand letter required before suing in Florida?
Not in every case. Some claims, such as construction defect claims under Chapter 558, and many contracts require written notice before suit. Even when it is not required, a demand letter is usually a good first step.
How long should I give someone to respond to a demand letter?
Give a reasonable, specific deadline based on the amount and complexity. If your contract sets a notice or cure period, follow it.
Can a demand letter be used as evidence?
Yes. Demand letters and responses can become evidence in a later lawsuit, which is why they should be accurate and carefully worded.