Breach of Fiduciary Duty: When a Partner, LLC Manager, or Officer Puts Themselves First
Business partners, LLC managers, and corporate officers owe duties of loyalty and care. Here is what a breach of fiduciary duty looks like in a Florida business and what you can do about it.
A fiduciary is someone who is legally required to act in another person's interest, not just their own. In business, that usually means partners, LLC managers (and in some LLCs, members), corporate directors and officers. When one of them uses their position to benefit themselves at the expense of the company or the other owners, that can be a breach of fiduciary duty.
Who owes fiduciary duties in a Florida business
- General partners owe duties to the partnership and to each other.
- In a manager-managed LLC, managers owe duties to the company and its members. In a member-managed LLC, the members who manage generally do.
- Corporate directors and officers owe duties to the corporation.
- Majority or controlling owners can owe duties in some circumstances, particularly in closely held companies.
Florida's LLC and partnership statutes describe these duties, and an operating agreement or partnership agreement can shape them within limits. The core duties of loyalty and care generally cannot be eliminated entirely.
The duty of loyalty
This is where most disputes arise. Common examples include:
- Taking a business opportunity that belonged to the company.
- Running a competing business on the side.
- Self-dealing, like steering company contracts to a business the manager secretly owns.
- Paying yourself unauthorized compensation or using company funds for personal expenses.
- Hiding information that other owners are entitled to see.
The duty of care
The duty of care is about how decisions are made. It is generally not breached by an honest business decision that turns out badly. Liability usually requires something more serious, such as gross negligence, reckless conduct, or knowing violations of law.
What you have to prove
A breach of fiduciary duty claim generally requires:
- A fiduciary duty existed.
- The duty was breached.
- The breach caused damages.
Some claims belong to the company rather than to an individual owner. If a manager took money from the LLC, the harm is usually to the LLC, and the claim may need to be brought as a derivative claim on the company's behalf. That distinction can affect who can sue and what steps have to be taken first.
Remedies
- Damages for the losses caused.
- Disgorgement of profits the fiduciary made from the breach.
- An accounting, which forces a full review of the books.
- Removal of a manager or, in serious cases, dissolution or a buyout.
- Punitive damages in some cases of intentional misconduct.
Warning signs
- You stop getting financial statements or access to the books.
- Revenue drops while expenses to unfamiliar vendors climb.
- A partner becomes evasive about a new venture.
- Customers mention dealing with your partner under another company name.
If you see these signs, request records in writing, keep copies of what you have, and avoid self-help steps such as locking a partner out of accounts without advice. Those moves can create claims against you.
Breach of fiduciary duty claims are subject to filing deadlines, and the timing rules can be complicated, so do not wait. Our partnership and shareholder dispute attorneys can help you sort out what claims you have and who owns them. Contact us to schedule a consultation.
Sources
Frequently Asked Questions
Do LLC members owe fiduciary duties in Florida?
It depends on how the LLC is managed. In a member-managed LLC, members generally owe duties of loyalty and care. In a manager-managed LLC, the managers generally do, and members who are not managers usually do not, subject to the operating agreement and the statute.
Can I sue my business partner for taking money from the company?
Often, yes, but the claim may belong to the company and need to be brought derivatively. Partners and members in smaller companies sometimes can sue directly, depending on the facts.
What is an accounting?
An accounting is a remedy in which the person who controlled the money must provide a full record of what came in and went out, so the court can determine what is owed.