Business Partner Disputes in Florida: Buyouts, Deadlock, and Leaving an LLC
When co-owners stop getting along, the business can freeze. Here are the options Florida law and your operating agreement may give you, from a negotiated buyout to court-ordered dissolution.
Partnerships often start with a handshake and a shared goal. Years later, the owners may disagree about money, workload, growth, or whether to sell. Sometimes one partner wants out. Sometimes trust breaks down entirely. Lawyers call this a "business divorce," and like any divorce, it goes much better with a plan.
Start with your governing documents
Before anything else, find the operating agreement (for an LLC), shareholder agreement or bylaws (for a corporation), or partnership agreement. These documents often answer the most important questions:
- How decisions are made and what requires unanimous consent.
- Whether and how a member can be removed or expelled.
- Buy-sell provisions, including triggering events, valuation methods, and payment terms.
- Restrictions on transferring ownership.
- Mediation or arbitration requirements for disputes.
If your company never adopted a written agreement, Florida's default statutes fill the gaps. For LLCs, that is the Florida Revised Limited Liability Company Act, Chapter 605. The defaults may not be what anyone expected.
Option 1: A negotiated buyout
Most partner disputes end in a buyout, with one side purchasing the other's interest. The big issues are price and payment terms. Valuation can depend on the method in the agreement, on whether discounts for minority interest apply, and on the quality of the financial records. A properly documented buyout should also address releases, personal guarantees on company debt, and who keeps which customers.
Option 2: Removing a member from an LLC
Whether you can remove a member depends heavily on the operating agreement. Without a provision allowing expulsion, removing someone against their will is difficult. Florida law does allow a court to dissociate a member in certain situations, such as wrongful conduct that adversely and materially affects the business or conduct that makes it not reasonably practicable to carry on the business with that person. Dissociation removes their management rights; the economic side of their interest has to be dealt with separately.
Option 3: Leaving the company yourself
Walking away is not as simple as it sounds. You may still own your interest, you may still be on personal guarantees, and you may still have obligations under your agreements. Make sure your exit is documented, any guarantees are addressed, and you understand what happens to your share of the value.
Option 4: Judicial dissolution
When there is no workable way forward, Florida law allows a court to dissolve an LLC or corporation in certain circumstances, including when:
- The owners or managers are deadlocked and the business cannot be conducted.
- Those in control have acted illegally or fraudulently.
- Company assets are being misappropriated or wasted.
- It is not reasonably practicable to carry on the business under the governing documents.
Dissolution is a serious step. Courts can sometimes order alternatives, and in some cases the other owners can elect to buy out the petitioner at fair value instead. Often the threat of dissolution is what brings both sides to a buyout.
When the dispute involves misconduct
If a partner has diverted money, taken opportunities, or hidden records, you may have claims for breach of fiduciary duty, conversion, or an accounting. Those claims can significantly change the buyout math.
Things not to do
- Locking a partner out of accounts or the office without legal advice.
- Moving company money "for safekeeping."
- Starting a competing business before your exit is resolved.
- Badmouthing your partner to employees, customers, or lenders.
Self-help steps like these often turn a manageable dispute into a lawsuit, and they can create claims against you.
Our partnership and shareholder dispute attorneys help owners negotiate exits, enforce buy-sell provisions, and litigate when necessary. Contact us to schedule a consultation.
Sources
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I force my business partner out of our Florida LLC?
It depends on your operating agreement. Without an expulsion provision, removal usually requires a negotiated buyout or a court order, such as judicial dissociation for serious misconduct.
What happens if LLC members are deadlocked?
Check the operating agreement for tie-breaking or buy-sell provisions. If none apply, a Florida court may order dissolution when the business cannot be conducted, and a buyout is often negotiated instead.
How is a partner's interest valued in a buyout?
Usually by the method in the governing agreement. Without one, the parties negotiate or rely on a business valuation, and issues like minority discounts and the quality of financial records can significantly affect the number.